[Kal]

I fully agree that ideas need to be thought through as well as their knock on ideas to other aspects of the game. What we need is a cohesive set of ideas that when combined form a decent whole that address all the issues with the game (though this would probabaly require an end to the current piece-meal development).

I don't object to people pointing out flaws in ideas, as thats exactly what should be happening on the forums and precisly why ideas should be posted.

Say for example I was still a member of PATeam - wouldn't it have been a good idea that the bad idea was posted for comment, rather than just being implemented? I think everyone would agree it would be.

Now maybe I mininterpreted the game's post, but I got the genuine impression he thought that if I was in PATeam the idea would simply have been implemented without any thought - I'd like to think that I'm not quite that stupid...

Ideas should be freely discussed and debated - what is then needed is for someone to pick them all up and join together then ones that will work together.