Quote:
Originally Posted by zPeti
I am quite annoyed about the responses I have gotten.
However, I definately agree with some of the criticism.
I like the general design, colours, boxes etc, and I most certainly will not be changing them. As I am glad a designer pointed out in the thread earlier, the r23 skin had way to many colours, it had too much information on it, it was extremely unclear for new players, and very daunting.
I have watched 3-4 people signup with the r23 skin and they had absolutely no idea where to start because of all the information, and then looked at me like wtf is this when they signed in and saw 10 different colours of messages.
I think the general colour design of the new skin is better, and it isn't as daunting.
However, I agree that the image sucks. So does anyone have some suggestions about what should replace it? I have a big batch of planetarion images (some of which are on MrLobsters design), and I could integrate those.
I understand the problem with the image, and I am up for changing it as I appreciate the feedback. I'm not sure what the problem is with the actual colours and boxes though.
|
well as said before i like the direction this is going, however i suggested some changes
to be found here:
http://pirate.planetarion.com/showpo...2&postcount=13
additional
i think the boxes should all be designed the same (like the Menu and Bulletin ones)
cause those colours look better and the overall look would be much better with 1 design instead of 2
the top frame buttons, need 1) the same layout then the boxes (again like Menu and Bulletin) and 2) some more hovering effect then just underlining)
i´d wish to see a flash designed topframe tbh
the spaceship is totally crap, think thats obvious by now
there is 3 options imo.
A) no spaceship and just a background
similiar to one of those:
http://www.eubaumgartner.ch/images/planeten1.jpg
http://www.planetarium-hamburg.de/fi...aneten_003.jpg
http://www.gratis-foto.eu/data/media...en_gruen_1.jpg
those suggestions i found in 2 minutes, they are not the ones i´d choose, they are just to point out what i mean
B) a spaceship
something cool pls and no tractor without tyres
c) both A and B combined
aswell the logo is crap (sorry) and it should be further on the left
while Planetarion should be written bigger (so the first you get to see is the logo and the name)
regarding those graphics (if your unsure if you can use old PA stuff)
why not have a competition, or 3 ones
get ppl to design
a logo
a background
a spaceship
in like 2 weeks
then have the community vote and the winner gets a free credit in each category
ofc ppl would have to agree that their gfx may be used by Fubra/Planetarion
this way you 1) get some better pics, i am pretty sure there is some real cracks out there and 2) you have the community take part in the process of the new PA
in germany you would say you catch two flies in one go