[Almeida]

i have been against this rule back when it was brought up and i am still against it.

if the out of tag members receive defense from ingame 1uppers it ain't against the rule.
if the out of tag members crossdef each other it ain't against the rule.
if the out of tag members def the intag members on a regular basis, then it would break the rule.
Attacking together never was against any rule.

imo 1up is playing it well and there really is no need to add a planet with ~80mill res /each stockpiled to the tag atm. if they can win the round with this strategy, then well done.

if any of the out of tag 1uppers get closed coz they defended ingame 1uppers then it might be backed up by this rule but imo it would be as stupid as the closings of eXi scanners deffing intag eXi back in r15.

btw, it's not 1ups fault that the Universe lets those out of tag members grow. they could be roided to the ground or at least forced to join 1up with sending enough FI/CO waves (no possibility do def against eta 7 unless u are in the ally, except cluster/ingal def)